Park Slope Loses a Landmark: What's Next for Brooklyn's LGBTQ+ Bar Scene?

For two decades, Excelsior stood as a vibrant beacon on Park Slope's Fifth Avenue, a haven for the LGBTQ+ community and a mainstay of Brooklyn nightlife. Now, the news has hit hard: the longest-running gay-owned and operated bar in the neighborhood is closing its doors. July 31st marks the end of an era, leaving many to wonder what the future holds for queer spaces in this rapidly changing corner of New York City.

The End of an Era: Why Excelsior Closed

Owners Richard Kennedy and Mark Nayden cited rising costs as the primary driver behind the difficult decision. In a heartfelt letter posted on Facebook, they expressed gratitude to their patrons, staff, performers, and the wider community, acknowledging the vital role Excelsior played in so many lives. "We hope you will join us and show your pride," they wrote, an invitation to celebrate the bar's legacy in its final days.

The closure of Excelsior reflects a larger trend impacting Park Slope and beyond. Many beloved local businesses are struggling to stay afloat amidst escalating rents and operating expenses. It's a somber reminder that even cherished institutions are not immune to the pressures of economic change. Does this signal a shift in the landscape of the neighborhood, or can other queer spaces step up to fill the void?

A Look Back: More Than Just a Bar

Excelsior was more than just a place to grab a drink. It was a community hub, a safe space, and a venue for unforgettable nights. Longtime patrons have been sharing memories online, recalling the bar as a touchstone for countless celebrations and a vital source of connection. The mention of "LennyPalooza and Tonyfaire shindigs" sparks a sense of shared history and the unique spirit that defined Excelsior.

The bar's impact extended beyond its immediate clientele. It fostered a sense of belonging and visibility for the LGBTQ+ community, particularly during a time when such spaces were less common. Its presence on Fifth Avenue served as a powerful statement of inclusivity and acceptance.

Brooklyn's Evolving LGBTQ+ Scene: Where to Go Now?

While the loss of Excelsior is deeply felt, Park Slope and surrounding neighborhoods still offer a variety of welcoming establishments. Here's a glimpse at some popular options:

Good Judy (5th Avenue): A self-described queer bar that welcomes everyone. Known for its creative cocktails and inclusive atmosphere, Good Judy embodies the spirit of community that defined Excelsior. Think tequila, pineapple, lime, and a Fernet float - a true taste of Brooklyn.
Ginger's Bar (Various locations): While the provided text offers no address, Ginger's is a well-known lesbian bar in Brooklyn that has fostered community for years.

Beyond these, consider these additional options, though they aren't exclusively LGBTQ+ bars, they are known to be welcoming:

Brooklyn Social (Address varies):
Branded Saloon (Various locations):
Union Hall (Various locations):
C'mon Everybody (Various locations):
The Holler (Various locations):
Happyfun Hideaway (Various locations):

Remembering Rising Cafe: A Precedent for Community

The story of Excelsior echoes a previous chapter in Park Slope's LGBTQ+ history: Rising Cafe. Founded in the 1990s by Kelli Blake, Rising Cafe served as a haven for the local lesbian community for seven years. Blake's conscious decision to locate the cafe on a less gentrified stretch of 5th Avenue highlights the importance of accessibility and inclusivity in creating safe spaces.

Rising Cafe hosted sports teams, literary events, and poetry readings, fostering a sense of community and belonging. Its closure serves as a reminder that these spaces require ongoing support and vigilance to thrive in the face of economic pressures.

Looking Ahead: Preserving Queer Spaces in Brooklyn

The closure of Excelsior raises important questions about the future of LGBTQ+ spaces in Brooklyn. How can we ensure that these vital community hubs continue to exist and thrive? What role do landlords, developers, and local government play in preserving cultural landmarks? How can community members actively support these spaces?

Here are a few ideas:

Support Local Businesses: Patronize LGBTQ+-owned and friendly establishments.
Advocate for Affordable Spaces: Support policies that promote affordable commercial rents.
Create Community: Organize events and gatherings that foster connection and belonging.

The legacy of Excelsior lives on in the memories of those who found solace, community, and joy within its walls. As Park Slope's LGBTQ+ community moves forward, it's crucial to remember the importance of creating and supporting spaces where everyone feels welcome, safe, and celebrated. What steps will you take to support the LGBTQ+ community in Brooklyn and beyond? The story of Excelsior is a call to action, a reminder that these spaces are not guaranteed - they require our ongoing commitment and support.